The Rev. Charles M. Atkinson
| Daniel McNair | 1847-1850 | |
| Nelson P. Chamberlain | 1850-1855 | |
| Robert S. McAllister | 1856-1859 | |
| N.P. Chamberlain | 1859-1866 | |
| R.S. McAllister | 1867-1869 | |
| Daniel McNair | 1869-1876 | Stated supply |
| Charles M. Atkinson | 1878-1891 | |
| Edward J. Young | 1891-1898 | |
| H.W. Wallace | 1898-1900 | |
| John N. Blackburn | 1900-1938 | |
| E.D. Pellitier | 1911 | |
| W.H. Leith | 1912-1913 | |
| Warner Dubose Jr. | 1938-1942 | |
| J. Holmes Smith III | 1943-1945 | |
| Walter A. Bader | 1945-1947 | |
| Robert G. Kilgore | 1947-1949 | Interim |
| Fitzhugh Clark | 1949-1953 | |
| David Shepperdson Jr. | 1953-1954 | Stated supply |
| Neil C. Leach | 1954-1959 | |
| Fred C. Low | 1957-1958 | Relief pastor |
| Gaylord Dodgen | 1960-1967 | |
| H. B. "Buddy" Chadwick | 1969-1991 | |
| Howard Lawson | 1991-1992 | Interim |
| Walter Hackney | 1992-1998 | |
| Louise S. Randall | 1998-2000 | Interim |
| Hollingsworth Mitchell | 2000-2001 | Interim |
| William Crawford | 2001- |